Review and Prospects of Taiwanese Philosophy Scholarship in South Korea
A Historical Survey of Academic Publications from 1994 to 2018
This study examined how Taiwanese philosophy has been received and researched in South Korea since its start to the present day. It takes the form of a survey, classifying the articles about Taiwanese philosophy which were published in South Korea over the years from 1994 to 2018 by the theme. It selected nine philosophers whose influence was profound in Taiwanese philosophy and observed the currents in the scholarship on each philosopher. The names of the selected philosophers are: Fang Thomé H., Hu Shi, Huang Chun-chieh, Lin Yutang, Liu Shuxian (Liu Shu-hsien), Mou Zongsan, Tang Junyi (Tang Chun-I), Xu Fuguan, Yu Yingshi (Yu Ying-shih). Sixty-one related papers were summarized and reviewed, and each of them was classified by the publication date, author, language, publisher and keywords. The survey revealed the limitations in Asian philosophy scholarship with regard to Taiwanese philosophy in South Korea, in terms of both quantity and quality. The survey also suggested a possible solution to these limitations and directions for scholars in the future. The study thus serves as a foundation that can boost discussion and the balanced development of South Korean philosophy studies, as well as of Asian philosophy in general.
Ahn, Jaeho 안재호. 2006. “Saengsaenghaneun dodeok 생생하는 도덕 (Tao and De, The Ceaseless Creator).” Cheolhaktamgu 철학탐구 19: 63–82.
Cho, Mi-won 조미원. 2005. “20segi honghaksa jeosul sitam 20 세기 홍학사 저술 시탐 (Study on the Writings of History of Red-ology (Hongxueshi) during Twentieth-Century).” Junggugeomunhangnonjip 중국어문학논집 33: 379–401.
Choi, Yeong-seong 최영성. 2000. “Dongyangcheolhak yeongu osimnyeonsa 동양철학 연구 오십년사 (50-year History of Eastern Philosophy in Korea).” Hanguksasanggwa munhwa 한국사상과 문화 10: 175–295.
Heubel, Fabian. 2019. “Beyond Murderous Dialectics: On Paradoxical Thinking and Maoism.” Asian Studies 7 (1): 37–54.
Huang, Chun-chieh. 2011. Ilbon noneo haeseokak 일본 논어 해석학 (A History of the Interpretations of the Analects in Tokugawa Japan). Translated by Yeong-ho I. Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University Press.
——. 2016. Icheonnyeon maengjareul ikda 이천년 맹자를 읽다 (The History of Mencius’ Thoughts). Translated by Yeong-dae Ham. Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University Press.
Jung, Woo Yeop 정우엽. 2017. “Mojongsamui jujahak haeseoge daehan bipan: jayulseong gaenyeomeul jungsimeuro 모종삼의 주자학 해석에 대한 비판: 자율성 개념을 중심으로 (Critique on Mou Zong San’s Interpretation for Zhu-xi Learning; Focusing on Autonomy).” MA thesis, Sogang University.
Kang, Byoung Yoong. 2019. Taiwanese Philosophy in Korea: A Comprehensive List of Research Papers on Taiwanese Philosophy in Korea between 1994 and 2018. Ljubljana: Znanstvena založba Filozofske fakultete.
Kim, Chan-ho 김찬호. 2018. “Mojongsamui wonseollon yeongu: yugajeong uimiui deokbogilchireul jungsimeuro 모종삼의 원선론 연구: 유가적 의미의 덕복일치를 중심으로 (A Study on MouZongSan’s Perfect Good).” MA thesis, Yeungnam University.
Lee, Cheol-seung 이철승. 2016 “Uricheolhagui hyeonhwanggwa gwaje(1) – geundae jeonhwangi tcheolhak’ yongeoui tansaenggwa oeraecheolhagui suyong munjereul jungsimeuro 우리철학의 현황과 과제(1) – 근대 전환기 ‘철학’ 용어의 탄생과 외래철학의 수용 문제를 중심으로 (The Current Status and Goals of Woori-Philosophy—The Birth of the Term ‘Philosophy’ and Acceptance of Foreign Philosophies in the Modern Transition Period).” Inmunhak yeongu 인문학연구 52 : 39–63.
Lee, Cheol-seung 이철승. 2017. “Uricheolhagui hyeonhwanggwa gwaje(2) – Saneopwasigi cheolhagui jedohwawa yeongu donghyangeul jungsimeuro 우리철학의 현황과 과제(2) – 산업화시기 철학의 제도화와 연구 동향을 중심으로 (The Current Status and Goals of Woori-Philosophy (2)—Focusing on the Institutionalization and Research Trend of Philosophy in the Industrialization Period).” Inmunhak yeongu 인문학연구 53: 37–69.
Lee, Gi-sang 이기상. 1999. “I ttangeseo cheolhakagi. Taljungsim sidaeeseoui jungsimjapgi 이 땅에서 철학하기. 탈중심 시대에서의 중심잡기 (Philosophy in Korea. Balance in the Decentering Era).” In I ttangeseo cheolhakagi 이 땅에서 철학하기 (Philosophy in Korea), edited by Urisasangyeonguso 우리사상연구소, 4–42. Seoul: Sol.
Lin, Yutang. 1991. Saenghwarui balgyeon 생활의 발견 (The Importance of Living). Translated by Gyeong-ja Ji. Seoul: Hongsinmunhwasa.
Liu, Shuxian. 1994. “Yugayeomirae(21segi)segyejeokjeonmang 유가여미래(21세기)세계적전망 (Confucianism and View of Future World).” Yugyosasangmunhwayeongu 유교사상문화연구 7: 147–59.
Luo, Gang. 2011. “Gyeokjinyeobosu: ryanggaesegimaljeokdaemangyeosangsang 격진여보수: 량개세기말적대망여상상 (Radicalization and Conservativeness: The Imagination and Correspondence of the Two Ends of the Century).” Junggungmunhwayeongu 중국문화연구 19: 237–55.
Min, Kyung Wook 민경욱. 2017. “Juhuijeongnyeoksasegyeui seosul gujowa nonjeung bangsige daehayeo: yeoyeongsiui juhuimanhyojongsijeonseoge daehan pyeongseogeul jungsimeuro 주희적력사세계의 서술 구조와 논증 방식에 대하여: 여영시의 주희만효종시전석에 대한 평석을 중심으로 (A Study of Narrative Structure and Methodology of Zhuxide lishishijie).” Jungeojungmunhak 중어중문학 67: 27–53.
NRF (National Reaseach Foundation of Korea). 한국연구재단. n. d. “Deungjaehaksuljimongnok 등재학술지목록” (The List of KCI (Korea Citation Index) Journals). Accessed September 17, 2019. https://www.nrf.re.kr/biz/journal/view?menu_no=13.
Oh, Byung-Soo’s 오병수. 2012 “Naengjeonsigi hojeogui bangong jayujuui noseonui hyeongseong 냉전시기 호적의 반공 자유주의 노선의 형성 (The Formation of Hu Shi’s Anti-Communist Liberalism in Cold War Era in China: The Ideologization of Chinese Liberalism (1941–1953).” Dongyangsahagyeongu 동양사학연구 118: 231–79.
Rošker, Jana S. 2014a. “The Philosophical Sinification of Modernity and the Modern Confucian Paradigm of Immanent Transcendence (內在超越性).” Asian Studies 2 (1): 67–81.
–––. 2014b. “Fang Dongmeijeva filozofija ustvarjalnega kozmosa.” Asian Studies 2 (2): 157–75.
Sernelj, Téa. 2014. “The Unity of Body and Mind in Xu Fuguan’s Theory.” Asian Studies 2 (1): 83–95.
Song, Yohan 송요한. 2017. “Kanteue daehan mojongsamui bipan geomto: hyeonsanggwa muljacheui gubuneul jungsimeuro 칸트에 대한 모종삼의 비판 검토: 현상과 물자체의 구분을 중심으로 (Mou’s Criticism on Kant: How is the Distinction between Things in Themselves and Appearance Possible?).” MA thesis, Sogang University.
Wonkwang University 원광대학교. n. d. “Gungnaedaehak cheolhakgwa 국내대학 철학과 (The List of Departments of Philosophy in South Korea).” Accessed September 17, 2019. https://philosophy.wku.ac.kr/?page_id=250.
Xu, Fuguan. 1990. Junggugyesuljeongsin 중국예술정신 (Chinese Art Spirit). Translated by Deok-ju Gwan. Seoul: Dongmunseon.
Yu, Yingshi. 2003. Scholar and Chinese Culture. Shanghai: Shanghai Peoples Publishing House.
–––. 2007. Dongyangjeok gachiui jaebalgyeon 동양적 가치의 재발견 (Modern Significance of Traditional Chinese Values System). Translated by Byeon-hwan Gim. Seoul: Dongasia.
–––. 2015. Juhuiui yeoksasegye 주희의 역사세계 (Zhu Xi’s Historical World). Translated by Weon-seok Yi. Paju: Geulhangari.
Yun, Ji-won 윤지원. 2016 “Bangdongmicheolhaksasangyeongu 방동미철학사상연구 (A Study on Fang Dong Mei’s Philosophy Thought).” Junggukangnonchong 중국학논총 52: 193–207.
Yun, Sa-Soon 윤사순, and Sung Tae-Yong 성태용. 1993. “Hangugyuhage daehan cheolhakjeok ihaeui munje: geu hoegowa jeonmang 韓國儒學에 대한 哲學的 理解의 問題: 그 회고와 전망 (Korean Confucianism Reconsidered).” Cheolhak 철학 39: 6–39.
Copyright (c) 2020 Byoung Yoong Kang
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors are confirming that they are the authors of the submitting article, which will be published (print and online) in journal Asian Studies by Znanstvena založba Filozofske fakultete Univerze v Ljubljani (University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Arts, Aškerčeva 2, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia). Author’s name will be evident in the article in journal. All decisions regarding layout and distribution of the work are in hands of the publisher.
- Authors guarantee that the work is their own original creation and does not infringe any statutory or common-law copyright or any proprietary right of any third party. In case of claims by third parties, authors commit their self to defend the interests of the publisher, and shall cover any potential costs.
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.